Business Law question ?

PART A:

ACME Transfer is a trucking company

On November 2nd , ACME wrote Kim Trang Pipe Works offering to carry less-than-truckload shipments to Hochiminh City for $1,25 / hundred kilos . The letter arrived on November 4th . On November 5th , Kim Trang Pipe accepted this offer in a letter that was not delivered to ACME until November 8th.In the meantime , on November 6th Kim Trang Pipe wired ACME , " In response to your offer , propose same term at $0,95 / hundred kilos . Wire answer earliest convenience" .ACME received this wire the same day and grudgingly wired back , "We accept" . Its respone was received by Kim Trang Pipe on November 7th

Is there a contract and , if so , what 's the rate ?

PART B:

During July , ACME negotiated with several construction firms for adding a new dispatch office to the side of its HCMC warehouse and terminal . The negotiations cost $1500 , and resulted in four offers between $12500 and $17000. Finally , on August 1st , ACME contracted with Truoc Construction to perform the work by October 1st at a cost of $12500.As required , ACME paid Truoc a downpayment of $3000 at the signing

Unfortunately , all of Truoc's tools and equipment were destroyed by fire the very next day , and its owners elected not to continue in business . Other contractors now seemed less interested in obtaining ACME's work , and ,after spending an additional $1000 . ACME received only one offer from Hanh Contracting for $16500 , also with completion by October 1st . ACME concluded that Hanh's price was too high in view of the facet that the new addition would only add $11000 to the fair market value of its building . Therefore , ACME declined Hanh's offer and instead bought two portable offices at a total cost $ 5000. These offices added nothing to the value of ACME's building.

Truoc admits its breach and offer to repay ACME its $3000 down payment in full settlement of all claims . Should ACME accept ? If not , how much would it accept and why ?

Part C

ACME 's terminal is 500 yards north of Dr Bich's Veterinary Clinic . Several times , " patients " had been scared by the roar of ACME's trucks as they passed her clinic , so , when she met ACME's General Director on the golf course , Dr. Bich said , " If your trucks will come and go to the north , so that they don't pass my clinic , for 1 year , I'll pay you $1000 for your trouble " . Since it didn't matter which direction the trucks left the terminal , the president agreed and ordered that drivers use the road to the north only when leaving or returning.

Of course , Dr.Bich refused to pay at the end of the year , and ACME brought an action to enforce the contract . At trial, the above was proven and ACME's dispatcher testified that , because of the opening of a new highway just north of the yard , he would have issued the same instructions to the drivers anyway , but for a different reason .

Who will win and why ?